Should Child Rapists be castrated?

Absolutely!

no they should just be in jail till there 80

They should have to do both because after doing something like that then they do not deserve a second chance

did you guys actually read the article? thats what it was there for.

that article says lower thier sex drive not castrate them

Either way, it's the government inducing a drug in your system to alter how your body works. is that ethical?

i think that would be filthy to have your parts melted off...but it is about lowering the sex drive, and if poland passes it, they obvoiusly have a reoccuring problem their that needs to be dealt with...Hell, that scares me, i'm pretty sure someone in that situation would take a hint and not be a sex offender

well is it ethical to rape a small child?

yes if the commit the crime they should pay for what they did whether it be the drugs or castrating them

Of course its not ethical to rape a kid.

They deserve to get the drugs put in them

exacly so if you rape a kid then i think they have every right to be unethical in thier punishment of the offender

so your stance on this is "if someone does something unethical, we should be just as brutal"

well i wouldnt say giving someone pills is as brutal as tying a kid down and
RAPING THEM!!

if someone commits a crime that is unethical then why should their punisment be ethical. That makes no sense.

I would say thats a little extreme. I propose jail (I would like to say death), but the problem with that is you are just confining them and not eliminating the problem.

That's why you give them the drugs

I'm not really sure how to approach this. I mean, from the biblical perspective, there's "do unto others as you would have them do unto you." however a situation such as this is... well, there are lots of different viewpoints on it. I guess in some ways, not only does it prevent the offender from offending again, but it also provides an example for would-be sex offenders.

Grim Ghandi wrote:well i wouldnt say giving someone pills is as brutal as tying a kid down and
RAPING THEM!!

I disagree, in both cases, things are happening to someone against our will. One isn't worse than the other.

I would say rape is worse

ya but the pills are to help solve the situation for next time without them the offender would just go do it again.

you have no idea if the offender would do it again.

biochemical modification is in no way unethical it is simply logical there is a difference. u can get these same drugs on request at the doctors

ya you do becauise with the pills they wouldnt be aroused